The Delhi High Court has ruled that ₹593.48 crore (approximately $63 million) in capital gains earned by Mauritius-based Emerging India Focus Funds from selling units of Indian equity-oriented mutual funds cannot be taxed in India under the India-Mauritius Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA). In its November 18, 2026, judgment, the court held that mutual fund units are legally different from equity shares, even when the funds invest predominantly in shares of Indian companies. The ruling is a significant development for cross-border investment structures using the India-Mauritius tax treaty.

The decision came in an appeal filed by the Income Tax Department against an earlier ruling by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). The department had argued that the underlying shares held by the mutual funds should determine the tax treatment of the investor’s gains. The High Court rejected that interpretation, holding that the investor owned mutual fund units rather than shares in the companies held by those funds. It therefore concluded that the gains fell under Article 13(4) of the treaty, which allocates taxing rights to the country where the seller is resident.

Key Takeaways

  • The Delhi High Court ruled in favour of Mauritius-based Emerging India Focus Funds on November 18, 2026.
  • The dispute involved ₹593.48 crore in capital gains from selling Indian equity-oriented mutual fund units during assessment year 2022-23.
  • The Income Tax Department initially sought to tax ₹385.76 crore, representing 65% of the gains.
  • The Dispute Resolution Panel subsequently held that the entire ₹593.48 crore should be taxable in India.
  • The court ruled that mutual fund units cannot be treated as equity shares simply because the funds invest in shares.
  • Article 13(4) of the India-Mauritius DTAA applies to the gains in this case, making them taxable only in Mauritius under the treaty.
  • The judgment upheld the earlier ITAT decision and dismissed the Income Tax Department’s appeal.

What Did the Delhi High Court Rule?

The Delhi High Court’s decision concerns the tax treatment of capital gains earned by a Mauritius-resident investment fund from selling units of equity-oriented mutual funds registered in India.

The case was titled Commissioner of Income Tax, International Taxation-1, New Delhi v. Emerging India Focus Funds, ITA 720/2025.

A division bench comprising Justices Subramonium Prasad and Renu Bhatnagar delivered the judgment on November 18, 2026.

The court examined whether capital gains from selling equity-oriented mutual fund units could be treated as gains from selling shares under Article 13(3A) of the India-Mauritius DTAA.

The Income Tax Department argued that the mutual funds invested primarily in Indian equity shares. Therefore, it said, the gains earned by the Mauritius-based investor should be treated as gains arising from the transfer of those underlying shares.

The court disagreed.

It held that the investor owned units in mutual fund schemes, not direct shares in the Indian companies held by those schemes. The legal distinction meant that the transaction did not fall within the treaty provision specifically dealing with the sale of shares.

Instead, the gains were covered by Article 13(4), which provides that gains from the sale of other property are taxable only in the country where the seller is resident.

Since Emerging India Focus Funds was a tax resident of Mauritius, the court held that the gains were taxable only in Mauritius under the treaty.

How Did the ₹593.48 Crore Tax Dispute Begin?

The dispute originated during assessment year 2022-23.

Emerging India Focus Funds is a foreign investment company and a tax resident of Mauritius. It is registered with the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) as a foreign institutional investor and invests in Indian financial markets.

According to the court judgment, the fund invested in SEBI-registered mutual funds and earned ₹593,48,24,274 in capital gains from selling units of equity-oriented mutual funds.

It declared total income of just ₹5,460 in its Indian income-tax return and claimed that the capital gains were exempt from Indian tax under the India-Mauritius DTAA.

The Income Tax Department selected the return for scrutiny and challenged the exemption.

Its argument was based on the composition of the mutual funds. Since equity-oriented funds invest more than 65% of their assets in domestic equity shares, the department believed that the corresponding proportion of the investor’s gains should be treated as gains from shares.

The dispute then moved through several stages.

How the Case Progressed

Date or stageDevelopment
Assessment year 2022-23Fund earned ₹593.48 crore in capital gains from mutual fund units
March 2024Assessing Officer proposed taxing ₹385.76 crore
December 2024Dispute Resolution Panel held that the entire gain should be taxable
June 25, 2025ITAT ruled in favour of the Mauritius-based fund
November 18, 2026Delhi High Court dismissed the Income Tax Department’s appeal

The ITAT held that mutual fund units and equity shares are different forms of securities and cannot automatically be treated as equivalent for the purpose of the treaty.

The Income Tax Department challenged that decision before the Delhi High Court. The High Court upheld the tribunal’s interpretation.

Why Did the Income Tax Department Want to Tax ₹385.76 Crore?

The assessing officer initially proposed taxing 65% of the fund’s total capital gains.

The reasoning was linked to the definition of an equity-oriented mutual fund under Indian tax law. Such a fund must invest more than 65% of its investible funds in equity shares of domestic companies, subject to the applicable statutory requirements.

The department argued that because the mutual funds held Indian shares, the investor’s gains from selling their units should be treated proportionately as gains from the underlying shares.

The calculation was:

ParticularsAmount
Total capital gains₹593.48 crore
Proportion initially treated as taxable65%
Amount initially proposed for taxation₹385.76 crore
Amount treated as taxable by the DRP₹593.48 crore
Final outcome at the Delhi High CourtExemption under Article 13(4) upheld

The Dispute Resolution Panel went further than the assessing officer. It reasoned that if equity-oriented mutual fund units were to be treated as shares, the entire capital gain should be taxable rather than only 65%.

The High Court rejected the underlying assumption that mutual fund units could be treated as shares for the purpose of Article 13(3A).

Why Are Mutual Fund Units Different From Equity Shares?

This distinction was central to the judgment.

When an investor purchases shares of a company, the investor becomes a shareholder in that company and receives rights associated with share ownership.

A mutual fund investor, however, purchases units in a scheme. The mutual fund is established as a trust and invests the pooled money in shares, bonds and other securities according to its investment objectives.

The investor owns units representing an interest in the assets of the mutual fund scheme. The investor does not directly become a shareholder in every company held by the fund.

The court relied on the definitions under the Companies Act, the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act and SEBI’s Mutual Fund Regulations.

It also noted that Indian law separately identifies equity shares and units of equity-oriented mutual funds.

Shares vs Mutual Fund Units

FeatureEquity sharesMutual fund units
What the investor ownsShares in a companyUnits in a mutual fund scheme
Legal relationshipShareholder of a companyUnit holder in a fund
Underlying investmentDirect ownership interest in a companyInterest in a pooled investment scheme
Investment managementInvestor makes direct investment decisionsFund manager manages the scheme
RightsRights associated with shareholdingRights associated with mutual fund units
Treaty treatment in this caseArticle 13(3A)Article 13(4)

The court’s reasoning was that the legal nature of the asset being sold matters. The fact that a mutual fund invests in shares does not automatically convert the investor’s units into direct share ownership.

How the India-Mauritius Tax Treaty Applies

The India-Mauritius DTAA determines how certain income and capital gains earned by residents of one country from investments in the other country are taxed.

The dispute centred on two provisions: Article 13(3A) and Article 13(4).

Article 13(3A): Gains From Selling Shares

Article 13(3A) was introduced through amendments to the India-Mauritius treaty.

It provides that capital gains from the sale of shares acquired on or after April 1, 2017, in a company resident in one contracting country may be taxed in that country.

For example, gains earned by a Mauritius-resident investor from selling qualifying shares acquired in an Indian company on or after the specified date can be taxed in India.

The Income Tax Department argued that this provision should also cover gains from equity-oriented mutual fund units because the underlying assets were Indian shares.

The High Court rejected this interpretation.

Article 13(4): Gains From Other Property

Article 13(4) covers gains from the sale of property not covered by the preceding provisions of the treaty.

It provides that such gains are taxable only in the contracting country where the seller is resident.

Because the court classified the mutual fund units as property distinct from shares, it applied Article 13(4) to the transaction.

In this case, the investor was tax resident in Mauritius, so the court held that the gains were taxable only in Mauritius under the treaty.

Treaty provisionType of transactionTax treatment relevant to the case
Article 13(3A)Sale of qualifying shares acquired on or after April 1, 2017India may tax gains from shares in an Indian-resident company
Article 13(4)Sale of other property, including the mutual fund units at issueTaxable only in the seller’s country of residence

The court also stressed that the treaty provisions must be interpreted according to the language agreed upon by India and Mauritius.

Supreme Court’s Apollo Tyres Judgment Also Influenced the Decision

The Delhi High Court relied on an earlier Supreme Court judgment in Apollo Tyres Ltd. v. CIT (2002).

That case considered whether units issued by the Unit Trust of India could be treated as shares for a particular purpose under the Income Tax Act.

The Supreme Court held that units could not automatically be treated as shares merely because certain statutory provisions treated the trust as a company or its distributions as dividends.

The Delhi High Court applied the same broader distinction: a legal provision that treats a particular investment in a specific way does not automatically transform the investment into a different legal asset.

This supported the court’s conclusion that mutual fund units should not be treated as shares merely because the underlying portfolio contains equity shares.

What Does the Ruling Mean for Foreign Portfolio Investors?

The judgment is relevant to foreign investors and fund structures that invest in Indian mutual fund units through Mauritius.

Mauritius has historically been an important jurisdiction for foreign investment into India because of its tax treaty arrangements.

The ruling clarifies how the Delhi High Court interprets the distinction between direct share investments and investments through mutual fund units under the India-Mauritius DTAA.

Potential implications include:

  • Mauritius-based investment funds: The judgment provides support for treating gains from mutual fund units separately from gains on direct equity shares.
  • Foreign portfolio investors: Tax advisers may examine whether similar treaty provisions apply to their investment structures.
  • Tax assessments: The ruling could become relevant in disputes involving the classification of mutual fund units.
  • Withholding tax decisions: Investors and intermediaries may consider the judgment when evaluating tax treatment, subject to the facts and documentation of each transaction.

However, the decision should not be interpreted as a blanket exemption for every foreign investor or every investment made through Mauritius.

Treaty benefits depend on factors such as tax residency, the nature of the asset sold, the relevant treaty provisions and applicable anti-abuse rules. The judgment also concerns a specific assessment year and a particular investment structure.

The Bigger Picture

The ruling highlights how the legal structure of an investment can determine its tax treatment in cross-border transactions.

Two investments may have similar economic exposure but different legal characteristics. An investor who directly owns shares in an Indian company is not necessarily in the same legal position as an investor who owns units in a mutual fund that holds those shares.

For India, the decision also illustrates the importance of precise treaty language when allocating taxing rights between countries. The Income Tax Department sought to look through the mutual fund structure to the underlying shares, but the court held that the treaty’s specific wording did not permit that approach in this case.

The judgment could influence tax planning and pending disputes involving Mauritius-based funds, although its application will depend on the particular facts and treaty provisions involved.

Looking Ahead

The Delhi High Court’s decision provides clarity on the treatment of capital gains from equity-oriented mutual fund units under the India-Mauritius DTAA. By distinguishing mutual fund units from direct equity shares, the court upheld the investor’s claim that the gains in this case were taxable only in Mauritius. The judgment also reinforces the importance of examining the legal nature of the asset transferred rather than relying solely on the composition of its underlying investments.

The ruling may be examined by foreign portfolio investors, fund managers and tax advisers dealing with cross-border investments into India. However, it does not automatically exempt all Mauritius-based investors from Indian capital gains tax, and other treaty routes may contain different provisions. The wider significance will depend on how tax authorities and courts apply the reasoning in future cases involving mutual fund units and other pooled investment structures.

Get the day’s top stories in your inbox

One concise email. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.