A District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in Panchkula, Haryana, has held Reliance Retail and Reliance Smart Superstore liable for deficiency in service and unfair trade practice after JioMart diverted part of a customer’s promised refunds into a digital rewards wallet without her consent. In an order dated October 28, 2026, the commission directed the companies to pay ₹2,500 in compensation to the customer and ₹5,000 in punitive damages to Haryana’s Free Legal Aid State Commission. The case involved just ₹1 diverted from each of two refunds, but raised a wider question about whether shopping platforms can force customers to accept wallet credit instead of money returned to their original payment method.

The commission also said the practice raised concerns about a deceptive dark pattern because wallet credit could encourage customers to make another purchase on the same platform to use the balance. The case was filed by Nishtha Raghav, a Panchkula resident, after two JioMart grocery orders included an unavailable chocolate product. Although the platform communicated that ₹19 would be refunded to her original payment method on each occasion, only ₹18 reached her bank account, with the remaining ₹1 transferred to her Twid rewards account.

Key Takeaways

  • Panchkula’s District Consumer Commission ruled against Reliance Retail and Reliance Smart Superstore in a JioMart refund dispute.
  • JioMart transferred ₹1 from each of two promised ₹19 refunds into the customer’s Twid rewards wallet.
  • The customer had not consented to the wallet adjustment, according to the commission’s findings.
  • The commission said the practice raised concerns about a deceptive dark pattern.
  • Reliance was directed to pay ₹2,500 compensation to the customer.
  • An additional ₹5,000 in punitive damages must be deposited with Haryana’s Free Legal Aid State Commission.
  • The companies were given 45 days from communication of the order to comply.
  • The decision highlights the importance of informed consumer consent when platforms process refunds.

What Happened in the JioMart Refund Case?

The dispute began with two grocery orders placed by Nishtha Raghav through the JioMart application on January 23 and January 25, 2026.

Both orders included a Munch Max chocolate bar priced at ₹19. However, the product was unavailable when the orders were processed.

JioMart communicated that a refund of ₹19 for the unavailable product had been initiated to the customer’s original payment method.

However, the refund breakdown showed a different outcome.

TransactionPromised refundBank refundTwid wallet credit
First order₹19₹18₹1
Second order₹19₹18₹1
Total₹38₹36₹2

The customer said she had not authorised the transfer of any portion of the refund into the rewards wallet.

The distinction was important because the platform had represented that the refunds would be returned through the original payment method.

A bank account and a digital rewards wallet are not interchangeable. While money credited to a bank account can generally be used or transferred independently, reward-wallet balances may be subject to restrictions and can encourage customers to transact again within a particular platform.

Customer Complained After JioMart Failed to Resolve the Issue

After noticing the difference between the promised and actual refunds, Raghav raised a complaint through the JioMart application on February 3, 2026.

According to the commission’s order, the grievance was marked as resolved without providing the relief she had requested.

She subsequently sent a legal notice to the companies on February 14.

The complaint alleged that the companies had failed to return the full refund through the original payment method despite communicating that the amount would be refunded that way.

The customer then approached the Panchkula District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission under Section 35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.

Reliance’s representatives appeared through legal counsel during the proceedings but did not file a written statement despite being given several opportunities. The commission struck off their defence on June 26, 2026.

However, the commission clarified that the absence of a written defence did not automatically entitle the complainant to the relief she sought. It examined her affidavit and supporting documents before reaching its decision.

Why Did the Consumer Commission Rule Against Reliance?

The commission focused on the difference between the refund promised to the customer and the amount actually credited to her bank account.

It observed that the company had communicated that ₹19 would be returned to the original payment method for each order.

Only ₹18 was credited to the bank account, while the

Get the day’s top stories in your inbox

One concise email. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.