The Supreme Court of India has upheld the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal’s (NCLAT) decision to send Twin Star Technologies’ ₹2,962 crore resolution plan for 13 Videocon Group companies back to lenders for reconsideration. The November 16, 2026, ruling dismisses appeals challenging the appellate tribunal’s January 2022 decision and reinforces its authority to return an approved insolvency resolution plan to the Committee of Creditors (CoC).
The case centres on a controversial takeover proposal that offered approximately ₹2,962 crore against admitted liabilities of around ₹65,000 crore. The arrangement would have resulted in a haircut exceeding 95% for creditors. Concerns over payments to dissenting lenders, discrepancies in financial calculations and the absence of required regulatory approval were among the reasons the original approval was overturned.
Supreme Court Upholds NCLAT’s Authority
A bench comprising Justices P.S. Narasimha and Alok Aradhe dismissed the appeals filed against the NCLAT’s decision.
While delivering its verdict, the Supreme Court affirmed that the appellate tribunal has the authority to send an approved resolution plan back to the Committee of Creditors for reconsideration. The bench also laid down guidelines governing how the NCLAT should exercise this power.
The court stated that it had upheld the NCLAT’s authority to return an approved resolution plan to the CoC and dismissed the appeals for the reasons outlined in its decision.
The ruling is significant because it addresses the scope of judicial and appellate oversight in India’s corporate insolvency framework. Although the commercial decisions of creditors generally receive considerable deference, resolution plans must still comply with the statutory requirements of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC).
A detailed written judgment was awaited at the time of the announcement.
How Much Did Twin Star Offer for Videocon?
The dispute originated from Twin Star Technologies’ proposal to acquire 13 companies belonging to the Videocon Group through the corporate insolvency resolution process.
Twin Star, backed by the Vedanta Group, offered approximately ₹2,962 crore for the companies. The Mumbai bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) approved the proposal on June 8, 2021.
However, the amount offered was significantly lower than the liabilities admitted during the insolvency proceedings.
| Particulars | Amount |
|---|---|
| Twin Star resolution offer | ₹2,962 crore |
| Admitted liabilities | Approximately ₹65,000 crore |
| Estimated creditor losses | Nearly ₹62,000 crore |
| Creditor haircut | More than 95% |
| CoC voting support | 95.09% |
The proposal received support from lenders representing 95.09% of the Committee of Creditors’ voting share.
Despite this approval, three financial creditors — Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI and the Small Industries Development Bank of India (SIDBI) — challenged the plan before the NCLAT.
Their objections focused on how the proceeds would be distributed and whether dissenting lenders were receiving the payments required under insolvency law.
Why Did Lenders Challenge the Resolution Plan?
The objections raised by the dissenting financial creditors centred on the treatment of their payments.
Under the resolution plan, some dissenting lenders were proposed to receive non-convertible debentures (NCDs) that would become redeemable after approximately five years.
The lenders argued that they could not be compelled to accept securities instead of the monetary payments required under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code.
The dispute also involved discrepancies between the compliance certificate submitted by the resolution professional and the distribution calculations prepared by SBI Capital Markets.
These differences raised questions about whether the proposed distribution complied with the legal requirements governing payments to dissenting financial creditors.
Another issue concerned the NCLT’s direction to replace the proposed debenture payments with cash. The NCLAT observed that changing the payment structure would effectively modify the resolution plan, a matter that should be considered by the Committee of Creditors rather than imposed through the tribunal’s approval process.
NCLAT Had Sent the Plan Back in January 2022
On January 5, 2022, the NCLAT overturned the NCLT’s approval of the resolution plan and returned the proposal to the Committee of Creditors.
The appellate tribunal concluded that the plan did not adequately comply with Section 30(2)(b) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, which establishes minimum payment protections for dissenting financial creditors.
The tribunal also highlighted the importance of regulatory compliance, particularly approval from the Competition Commission of India (CCI).
It found that the required competition approval had not been obtained before the Committee of Creditors cleared the proposal. Such statutory requirements could not simply be covered by the commercial wisdom of lenders.
Twin Star subsequently approached the Supreme Court, challenging the NCLAT’s decision.
The November 2026 ruling has now upheld the appellate tribunal’s decision, leaving the resolution proposal subject to reconsideration by the creditors.
What Happens to the Videocon Insolvency Process Now?
The Supreme Court’s decision means the original ₹2,962 crore resolution plan cannot proceed on the basis of the NCLT’s June 2021 approval.
The Committee of Creditors can reconsider the resolution process in accordance with the applicable insolvency framework. This includes addressing the concerns raised by the NCLAT and complying with statutory requirements.
According to a report by Mint, the CoC had previously decided to invite fresh expressions of interest following the NCLAT’s January 2022 order. The Supreme Court’s latest ruling reinforces the legal position underlying that decision.
The outcome could have implications for lenders seeking to recover value from Videocon’s assets. It also leaves the resolution process facing questions about how a fresh proposal should balance creditor recoveries, statutory payment protections and the commercial viability of the businesses.
The ruling does not mean creditors will automatically recover the full amount of their admitted claims. The eventual recovery will depend on the resolution process and the proposals that emerge from it.
Separate Dispute Over Videocon’s Overseas Oil and Gas Assets
The Videocon insolvency proceedings also involve a separate dispute over overseas oil and gas assets.
The group’s former chairman and managing director, Venugopal N. Dhoot, had sought to include foreign assets belonging to other Videocon entities in the insolvency process of Videocon Industries.
These assets included interests associated with Videocon Oil Ventures, Videocon Hydrocarbon Holdings, Videocon Energy Brasil and Videocon Indonesia Nunkan.
The argument concerned whether assets held by different group entities should be treated as part of Videocon Industries’ insolvency proceedings.
The Supreme Court also rejected Dhoot’s request to include those overseas assets, according to The Economic Times. The dispute involves separate corporate entities and raises questions about the treatment of assets held by companies undergoing distinct insolvency processes.
The Bigger Picture
The Supreme Court’s decision is important for India’s insolvency framework because it reinforces the requirement that resolution plans must comply with statutory protections, even when they receive overwhelming support from creditors.
The Videocon case demonstrates the tension between commercial decision-making by lenders and the legal safeguards designed to protect dissenting financial creditors. A high voting majority does not automatically make every provision of a resolution plan legally compliant.
The ruling also highlights the importance of regulatory approvals and accurate financial distribution calculations during insolvency proceedings. For banks and financial institutions, the outcome reinforces the need to ensure that creditor recovery arrangements follow the requirements of the IBC before receiving tribunal approval.
For India’s corporate insolvency market, the decision provides another indication that resolution plans can face significant legal scrutiny even after approval by lenders and the NCLT.
Looking Ahead
The next stage of the Videocon insolvency process will depend on the Committee of Creditors and the steps taken to address the objections raised by the NCLAT. Lenders will need to consider the treatment of dissenting creditors, payment structures and applicable regulatory approvals before a resolution proposal can move forward.
The Supreme Court’s ruling also carries implications beyond Videocon, particularly for companies undergoing insolvency proceedings and investors seeking distressed-business acquisitions. Resolution plans will need to balance commercial recovery objectives with statutory compliance, making legal and regulatory due diligence an essential part of India’s insolvency process.
Get the day’s top stories in your inbox
One concise email. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.



