A US federal judge has rejected an emergency request by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to prevent New York from pursuing enforcement action against prediction-market operator Kalshi. The November 20 decision allows New York Attorney General Letitia James to continue her case alleging that Kalshi offered unlicensed gambling services through contracts tied to sports, elections and other events.
US District Judge Lorna Schofield in Manhattan said the CFTC had not demonstrated a likelihood of success in arguing that federal derivatives law prevents states from enforcing their own gambling regulations against prediction-market platforms. The decision is another setback for Kalshi and the federal regulator in their dispute with New York. It does not, however, decide whether Kalshi’s event contracts are illegal gambling or federally regulated financial derivatives.
The ruling came a day after another federal judge, Vernon Broderick, sent New York’s enforcement lawsuit back to state court. The dispute is now set to return to Manhattan Supreme Court, where a state judge is expected to consider New York’s request for a temporary restraining order.
Key Takeaways
- CFTC loses emergency bid: Judge Lorna Schofield rejected the regulator’s request to temporarily block New York’s enforcement action against Kalshi.
- Federal preemption argument challenged: The judge said the CFTC had not shown a likelihood of success in arguing that federal law overrides state gambling regulations.
- Case returns to state court: Judge Vernon Broderick remanded New York’s lawsuit against Kalshi to Manhattan Supreme Court.
- New York seeks restrictions: Attorney General Letitia James alleges Kalshi needs a state gaming licence to offer event contracts to New York customers.
- Kalshi warns of nationwide impact: The company argues that an order restricting operations “from New York” could affect its entire exchange.
- Legal battle continues: Federal appeals courts are divided over whether states can regulate prediction-market sports contracts.
Why Did the US Judge Reject the CFTC’s Emergency Request?
The CFTC sought an emergency order to temporarily prevent New York from pursuing enforcement action against Kalshi.
The regulator argued that the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) gives it exclusive authority over derivatives markets and that states cannot use their gambling laws to restrict event contracts traded on federally regulated exchanges.
Kalshi operates as a designated contract market registered with the CFTC. Its platform allows customers to trade contracts based on the outcomes of events, including sports competitions, elections and other developments.
The CFTC considers these products financial derivatives, particularly swaps, that fall within its federal regulatory jurisdiction.
New York takes a different position. The state argues that contracts allowing users to wager on sporting outcomes function as gambling products and should comply with state gaming laws.
Judge Schofield rejected the CFTC’s request on November 20, finding that the agency had not established a likelihood of success on the merits of its federal preemption argument.
Federal preemption refers to the principle that federal law can override conflicting state laws in areas where Congress has given federal authorities regulatory power.
The judge’s decision means the CFTC could not use the requested emergency relief to stop New York’s enforcement action at this stage. It does not constitute a final ruling on the broader question of whether federal law preempts state gambling regulation of prediction markets.
How Did the Dispute Between Kalshi and New York Begin?
The dispute intensified in October 2025, when the New York State Gaming Commission issued a cease-and-desist notice to Kalshi over its sports event contracts.
The state argued that Kalshi was offering an unlicensed sports wagering service. New York requires operators offering regulated sports betting to obtain the relevant state authorisation and comply with rules covering age restrictions, permitted wagers and consumer protections.
Kalshi challenged the enforcement action, arguing that its contracts are derivatives regulated under federal law rather than ordinary sports bets governed by state gambling legislation.
The company subsequently pursued legal action against New York gaming authorities.
In July 2026, Judge Analisa Torres rejected Kalshi’s request for a preliminary injunction that would have prevented New York’s Gaming Commission from enforcing its gambling laws against the platform.
New York Attorney General Letitia James then filed a separate enforcement lawsuit on July 31, 2026. The lawsuit seeks to stop what the state describes as an unlicensed gambling business and alleges violations of multiple state laws.
Kalshi moved the case from state court to federal court, arguing that the dispute involved federal derivatives regulation.
The legal battle has since expanded beyond the original dispute between Kalshi and the state gaming regulator, drawing in the CFTC and raising questions about the division of authority between federal and state governments.
Federal Court Sends New York’s Lawsuit Back to State Court
The latest developments involve two separate federal court decisions.
On November 19, US District Judge Vernon Broderick granted New York’s request to remand its enforcement lawsuit against Kalshi to state court.
Broderick concluded that the federal court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction over the case. He also rejected New York’s request for attorneys’ fees and costs, finding that Kalshi had reasonable grounds for seeking to move the dispute to federal court.
The remand decision did not determine whether Kalshi violated New York gambling laws. It addressed which court should hear the state’s enforcement case.
The following day, Judge Schofield rejected the CFTC’s emergency request to stop New York from pursuing enforcement.
The two decisions have different legal consequences:
| Decision | Judge | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| New York’s request to return its lawsuit to state court | Vernon Broderick | Granted on November 19 |
| CFTC’s emergency request to block New York enforcement | Lorna Schofield | Rejected on November 20 |
With the case back in state court, New York can pursue its request for a temporary restraining order against Kalshi.
Kalshi Warns New York’s Proposed Order Could Shut Down Its Exchange Nationwide
Kalshi has argued that New York’s proposed restrictions could have consequences beyond the state.
The company is headquartered in New York. Its lawyers argue that an order preventing it from offering event contracts “within or from New York” could effectively force it to stop operating its exchange for customers across the United States.
Kalshi has also warned that such an order could require the liquidation of existing open positions and disrupt contracts involving sports, elections, culture and other events.
The company says the proposed restrictions could conflict with the CFTC’s emergency order issued in August 2026, which directed Kalshi to continue operating its exchange.
The CFTC issued that order after Kalshi notified the regulator that New York’s proposed restrictions could threaten the exchange’s ability to fulfil its obligations as a designated contract market.
New York Attorney General James has disputed the suggestion that the state is seeking to shut down Kalshi nationwide. Her office has said the proposed order is intended to prevent violations of New York law and would not prohibit Kalshi from offering lawful futures or swaps.
The geographic scope of any eventual state court order is therefore likely to be a significant part of the next stage of the dispute.
Why Does the CFTC Believe It Has Exclusive Authority?
The CFTC regulates US derivatives markets, including futures and swaps traded on regulated exchanges.
Its central argument is that Kalshi’s event contracts fall within the federal derivatives framework. Because the platform is registered as a designated contract market, the agency says state gambling authorities should not be able to impose separate licensing requirements on products that fall under federal regulation.
The Commodity Exchange Act gives the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over certain transactions involving commodity derivatives traded on designated contract markets.
The agency argues that allowing individual states to restrict these contracts could create a fragmented regulatory environment for exchanges operating nationally.
This is particularly important for prediction markets because their contracts can cover a wide range of outcomes, from economic indicators and political developments to sporting events.
However, state authorities argue that federal registration does not automatically exempt an operator from gambling laws when the products offered function as sports wagers under state law.
The disagreement is therefore not simply about whether Kalshi is registered with the CFTC. It concerns how the contracts should be legally classified and which regulator has authority over them.
Federal Appeals Courts Are Divided Over Prediction Markets
The legal uncertainty surrounding Kalshi has increased because federal appeals courts have reached different conclusions in disputes involving prediction markets and state gambling regulations.
According to Reuters, three federal appeals courts have ruled that states could regulate Kalshi, while a fourth reached a different conclusion in a dispute involving New Jersey.
The Third Circuit has sided with Kalshi in its dispute with New Jersey, while the Ninth, Sixth and Fourth Circuits have ruled in favour of state regulatory authority in separate cases.
These decisions do not resolve every legal question surrounding event contracts. Different courts have relied on different reasoning, including whether particular contracts qualify as swaps and whether federal derivatives law prevents states from enforcing gambling restrictions.
The disagreement among appeals courts increases the possibility that the US Supreme Court could eventually be asked to settle the broader question.
For prediction-market operators, the split creates uncertainty about where they can offer sports-related contracts and what state-level restrictions may apply.
What the Dispute Means for Kalshi and the Prediction-Market Industry
The case could have implications beyond Kalshi.
Prediction-market companies argue that event contracts provide users with a way to trade on expectations about real-world developments. They view these products as financial instruments that can help participants express views about future outcomes and manage risk.
State regulators, meanwhile, argue that sports-related contracts can operate like betting products and should be subject to gambling regulations designed to protect consumers.
The distinction matters because the two regulatory frameworks impose different obligations.
A platform operating under federal derivatives regulation faces requirements relating to exchange registration, market oversight and trading integrity. A state-regulated sports betting operator may face licensing conditions, age restrictions, responsible-gambling requirements and state taxes.
If states are permitted to regulate prediction-market sports contracts, companies could face different rules across jurisdictions. If federal law is found to preempt those state requirements, the CFTC’s authority over these products could become more significant.
The outcome could also influence the competitive position of other prediction-market platforms, including companies offering event-based contracts in the United States.
The Bigger Picture
The Kalshi dispute reflects a broader regulatory question emerging as prediction markets expand into sports, politics, economics and other areas of public interest. The same contract can be viewed as a financial derivative by a federal regulator and as a gambling product by a state authority. The disagreement is particularly important because federal exchanges operate across state borders, while gambling regulation has traditionally been handled largely by individual states. The latest court decisions have not settled that conflict, but they have allowed New York’s enforcement case to continue in state court.
For the prediction-market industry, the next phase will depend on how courts interpret the Commodity Exchange Act and the authority of state gaming regulators. A nationwide business model becomes harder to manage when legal treatment differs across jurisdictions. The split among federal appeals courts could eventually bring the issue before the Supreme Court, which may have to clarify the boundaries between derivatives regulation and state gambling laws. Until then, operators, regulators and customers will continue to face uncertainty over the legal status of event contracts.
What Happens Next?
New York’s enforcement case is returning to Manhattan Supreme Court, where Attorney General Letitia James is seeking a temporary restraining order against Kalshi. A state court hearing was scheduled for November 23, 2026, to consider the request. Kalshi has asked to receive notice and an opportunity to respond before any renewed emergency order is issued. The scope of the proposed restrictions, particularly the phrase “within or from New York”, could become a central issue.
Separately, the CFTC is continuing its wider legal effort to defend federal authority over prediction markets. The division among federal appeals courts could eventually lead to Supreme Court review. Until a final decision emerges, the legal position of sports-related prediction contracts will remain contested, and the November 20 ruling should be understood as a rejection of emergency relief rather than a final decision on the underlying regulatory dispute.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why did a US judge reject the CFTC’s request against New York?
Judge Lorna Schofield rejected the CFTC’s emergency request because the regulator had not demonstrated a likelihood of success in arguing that federal derivatives law prevents New York from enforcing its gambling regulations against Kalshi.
2. What is Kalshi?
Kalshi is a US-based prediction-market exchange that allows users to trade contracts linked to the outcomes of real-world events, including sports, elections and economic developments. It operates as a designated contract market registered with the CFTC.
3. What does New York accuse Kalshi of doing?
New York Attorney General Letitia James alleges that Kalshi offered sports-related event contracts without obtaining the required state gaming licence. The state argues that these products fall within its gambling regulatory framework.
4. Why does the CFTC support Kalshi?
The CFTC considers Kalshi’s event contracts derivatives, including swaps, that fall under its federal regulatory authority. It argues that state gambling laws cannot override the federal framework governing these exchange-traded products.
5. Could New York shut down Kalshi nationwide?
Kalshi argues that a proposed order restricting operations “within or from New York” could force it to shut down its exchange nationwide because the company is headquartered in the state. New York has disputed that it is seeking a nationwide shutdown. The final scope of any order remains for the state court to determine.
6. Has the court ruled that Kalshi is operating illegally?
No. Judge Schofield rejected the CFTC’s emergency request, while Judge Broderick returned New York’s enforcement lawsuit to state court. Neither November ruling finally determined whether Kalshi’s contracts violate New York gambling laws.
7. Could the US Supreme Court decide the prediction-market dispute?
Yes. Federal appeals courts have reached different conclusions about whether states can regulate Kalshi’s sports-related contracts. That disagreement increases the possibility of eventual Supreme Court review, although no final decision on such review has been made.
Get the day’s top stories in your inbox
One concise email. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.



