Visa and Mastercard have urged a US federal judge to grant final approval to a proposed $38 billion settlement aimed at resolving a long-running legal battle over credit card processing fees. The agreement would introduce lower interchange fees, give merchants greater flexibility in deciding which cards to accept and modify payment network rules that retailers have challenged for years. The proposal covers more than 12 million merchants in the United States.

However, the settlement continues to face opposition from major retailers and industry associations, including Walmart and the National Retail Federation. Critics argue that the proposed changes do not go far enough to address the high costs associated with premium rewards cards and commercial credit cards. US District Judge Brian Cogan did not issue a final decision at the November 16 hearing, leaving the agreement’s future uncertain.

What Is the $38 Billion Visa and Mastercard Settlement?

The proposed settlement is designed to resolve litigation dating back to 2005, when merchants accused Visa, Mastercard and participating banks of using anti-competitive practices to maintain high credit card processing fees.

These charges, commonly known as swipe fees or interchange fees, are paid by merchants whenever customers use credit cards. They are generally collected through the payment ecosystem and distributed among card-issuing banks, payment networks and other participants.

Retailers have argued that the fees increase their operating expenses and reduce profit margins. Businesses with large transaction volumes can face substantial annual costs, particularly when customers frequently use premium credit cards that carry higher processing charges.

The revised settlement, negotiated by the parties after an earlier agreement was rejected, is expected to deliver an estimated $38 billion in merchant savings through 2031, according to economic experts hired by the plaintiffs.

Importantly, the $38 billion figure represents projected savings from changes to payment fees and rules. It is not a direct cash payment of $38 billion to merchants.

Key Changes Under the Proposed Settlement

The agreement introduces several changes to the way Visa and Mastercard credit card transactions are priced and accepted.

Proposed changeWhat it means
Lower interchange feesAverage effective credit interchange rates would fall by 0.1 percentage point for five years
Standard card fee capInterchange rates on standard consumer credit cards would be capped at 1.25% for eight years
Flexible card acceptanceMerchants could choose among standard consumer, premium consumer and commercial card categories
More surcharge flexibilityMerchants would receive additional options to charge customers for using certain credit cards
Customer discountsBusinesses could offer discounts to encourage customers to use lower-cost payment methods

The changes are intended to give merchants more control over payment acceptance while reducing some of the costs associated with card transactions.

Reduction in Swipe Fees

One of the most important provisions is the proposed reduction of average effective credit interchange rates by 0.1 percentage point over five years.

The agreement also proposes a cap of 1.25% on interchange rates for standard consumer credit cards for eight years.

These provisions could provide some relief to retailers, although the actual savings would depend on their transaction volumes, card mix and existing processing arrangements.

Changes to the ‘Honor All Cards’ Rule

The settlement also addresses one of the longstanding disagreements between merchants and payment networks: the ‘Honor All Cards’ rule.

Under the existing framework, businesses that accept a particular payment network’s cards generally have to accept all cards issued under that network, subject to applicable rules.

The proposed settlement would allow merchants to make separate acceptance decisions for three broad categories:

  • Standard consumer credit cards.
  • Premium consumer credit cards, including rewards cards.
  • Commercial credit cards.

This could allow businesses to decline certain higher-cost card categories while continuing to accept other cards from the same payment network.

However, merchants would not receive unlimited freedom to select individual issuing banks within each category.

Why Walmart and Retail Groups Oppose the Deal

Despite the proposed changes, the settlement has attracted significant opposition from retailers that believe it does not adequately address the underlying competition problems in the credit card industry.

Walmart and the National Retail Federation are among the prominent opponents. The court received slightly more than 1,000 objections to the agreement.

Critics argue that premium consumer and commercial cards account for more than 90% of the relevant card market. These products often carry higher interchange fees, making them particularly important to merchants concerned about payment costs.

Retail groups also argue that popular rewards programmes make it difficult for businesses to reject premium cards without risking customer dissatisfaction.

Another concern is the absence of meaningful competition among card-issuing banks. Merchants want greater flexibility to accept cards from one bank while rejecting cards from another, even when both operate on the same payment network.

Mithun Mansinghani, an attorney representing the National Association of Convenience Stores and Circle K, argued that the agreement does not introduce structural reforms capable of creating meaningful competition among card issuers.

The objections highlight a central disagreement: whether reducing certain fees and changing acceptance rules will meaningfully improve competition or simply provide limited relief while preserving the existing payment system.

Visa and Mastercard Defend the Settlement

Visa and Mastercard have argued that the agreement represents a meaningful compromise and would provide substantial benefits to businesses.

Their lawyers told the court that the proposed changes would fundamentally alter some longstanding relationships between payment networks and merchants.

The companies also argued that rejecting the settlement could prolong litigation and expose merchants to the uncertainty of a trial and subsequent appeals.

Judge Brian Cogan acknowledged the possibility of a lengthy legal process if the agreement were rejected. However, he did not announce a final decision during the November 16 hearing.

The settlement received preliminary approval in June 2026. That decision allowed it to proceed to the final approval stage but did not make the agreement legally final.

Swipe Fees Have Become a Major Expense for US Retailers

The dispute reflects the growing financial importance of credit card processing fees for American businesses.

According to figures from the Merchants Payments Coalition cited by Reuters, Visa and Mastercard interchange fees in the United States reached $118.8 billion in 2025, compared with $111.2 billion in 2024 and $25.6 billion in 2009.

The average fee was approximately 2.36%.

YearVisa and Mastercard interchange fees
2009$25.6 billion
2024$111.2 billion
2025$118.8 billion

The increase illustrates why retailers have repeatedly challenged the payment networks’ fee structures.

For businesses operating on relatively thin margins, even small changes in transaction costs can have a significant impact on profitability.

Retailers have also argued that payment processing expenses can eventually contribute to higher prices for consumers. However, the extent to which any individual business passes these costs on to customers varies.

What Happens If the Settlement Is Rejected?

If the judge refuses to grant final approval, the legal dispute could continue through further proceedings, potentially including a trial.

That would extend litigation that has already lasted more than two decades.

The current agreement followed the rejection of an earlier $30 billion proposal in 2024. A different judge concluded that the previous settlement did not provide sufficient relief to merchants.

The revised agreement includes additional fee restrictions and changes to card acceptance rules in an effort to address some of those concerns.

The latest court decision will therefore be important for both sides. Approval would move the litigation closer to resolution, while rejection could reopen negotiations or send the parties into a prolonged legal battle.

The Bigger Picture

The Visa and Mastercard dispute highlights the growing tension between digital payment convenience and the cost of operating the infrastructure behind card transactions. Credit cards remain an important payment method for consumers, while merchants increasingly want greater control over the fees they pay to accept them. The proposed settlement attempts to balance these interests through lower interchange rates and more flexible acceptance rules, but opposition from major retailers shows that the industry’s competitive structure remains controversial.

The outcome could also influence how payment networks negotiate with merchants in the future. If approved, the agreement would establish new rules for a substantial portion of the US credit card market. However, it would not resolve every concern about processing costs, rewards programmes or competition among issuing banks. The final decision will determine whether the proposed changes are considered sufficient to settle one of the payment industry’s longest-running legal disputes.

Looking Ahead

The immediate focus is on Judge Brian Cogan’s decision on final approval. Visa and Mastercard are seeking to bring the 21-year-old litigation closer to an end, while opponents want stronger measures to reduce fees and increase competition. Until the court issues its decision, the proposed settlement should not be treated as a final, legally approved resolution.

For merchants, the potential benefits will depend on the final terms and how effectively businesses can use the new acceptance and surcharge options. For Visa, Mastercard and issuing banks, the agreement could require adjustments to established commercial arrangements. Regardless of the outcome, the dispute has renewed attention on the economics of card payments and the balance of power between payment networks, banks, retailers and consumers.

Get the day’s top stories in your inbox

One concise email. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.